Roofing Felt vs Tar Paper: Key Differences and Uses Explained
When selecting materials for waterproofing your roof, two common options often come up: roofing felt and tar paper. Both serve critical functions in protecting buildings from moisture and weather damage during construction and in the long term. Although these terms are sometimes used interchangeably, understanding the important distinctions between roofing felt and tar paper can help homeowners, contractors, and builders make informed decisions suited to their specific roofing needs.
| Aspect | Roofing Felt | Tar Paper |
|---|---|---|
| Material Composition | Fiberglass or organic base saturated with asphalt | Organic paper base impregnated with tar or asphalt |
| Thickness | Usually thicker, 15 lb or 30 lb weights | Generally thinner, lighter weight |
| Durability | More durable, tear-resistant | Less durable and easier to tear |
| Moisture Resistance | High resistance due to fiberglass and asphalt | Moderate, primarily due to tar content |
| Common Use | Underlayment for shingles, roofing membranes | Temporary roof protection, underlayment in older constructions |
| Cost | Typically higher price | Lower cost, budget-friendly option |
What Is Roofing Felt?
Roofing felt is a traditional underlayment material used beneath shingles and other roofing materials. It is composed of either an organic or fiberglass base mat that is saturated with asphalt to ensure water resistance. Fiberglass felt is more common today due to its superior durability, fire resistance, and tear strength compared to older organic felts made from wood cellulose or rags.
Roofing felt is available in different weights, most commonly 15-pound (lb) and 30-pound variants. The 30-lb felt is thicker and more robust, often used in regions with harsher weather conditions for extra protection. Its primary purpose is to provide a waterproof barrier that protects the roof decking during installation and throughout the roof’s lifespan.
What Is Tar Paper?
Tar paper is a type of roofing underlayment made from paper or cellulose fibers impregnated with tar or asphalt. It dates back many decades and was historically a popular choice as a water-resistant layer in roofing systems. Tar paper tends to be thinner and less durable than modern fiberglass roofing felt.
Its primary function is temporary protection during roof construction and providing a moisture barrier beneath roofing materials. Though affordable and easy to work with, tar paper is more prone to tearing and can degrade faster when exposed to UV rays or extreme weather conditions.
Material Composition and Differences
The key difference lies in the base material and saturation process. Roofing felt utilizes fiberglass mats or organic fibers saturated with asphalt, making it thicker and more tear-resistant.
Tar paper, on the other hand, uses paper or cellulose fibers that are impregnated with a tar-based substance, resulting in a lighter and more flexible sheet but typically less durable.
| Feature | Roofing Felt | Tar Paper |
|---|---|---|
| Base Material | Fiberglass or organic mat | Paper or cellulose |
| Waterproofing Agent | Asphalt saturated | Tar impregnated |
| Thickness | Thicker (15 lb & 30 lb) | Thinner |
| Tear Resistance | High | Low |
Durability and Weather Resistance
Roofing felt provides greater durability due to its fiberglass base and asphalt saturation. It withstands tearing, wind uplift, and sun exposure better than tar paper. This makes roofing felt more suitable for long-term applications and as a protective layer during extended roofing projects.
Conversely, tar paper is more vulnerable to damage from mechanical stress and UV exposure, so it is typically used for short-term protection or in low-budget projects where longevity is less critical.
Typical Applications and Usage
Roofing felt is widely used as a primary underlayment beneath asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and synthetic membranes. It acts as a moisture barrier, protecting roof decking from water infiltration in case of shingle damage or ice dams.
In contrast, tar paper is often found in older homes or as a temporary weather barrier during construction. It can also be used in areas with limited exposure requirements, such as sheds or garages.
Cost Comparison
Tar paper is generally less expensive due to its simpler manufacturing process and materials. However, its lower durability may lead to increased maintenance or earlier replacement, potentially offsetting initial savings.
Roofing felt costs more upfront but offers better protection and longer lifespan, making it cost-effective for most residential and commercial roofing projects.
Installation Considerations
Both roofing felt and tar paper rolls are installed starting from the eaves upward, overlapping each row to ensure water sheds properly. They are typically nailed or stapled to the plywood or OSB decking.
Roofing felt’s superior strength allows it to resist tearing during installation, especially in windy conditions. Some types are self-adhesive, simplifying application and improving waterproofing.
Tar paper installation requires more care to prevent tearing, and its lighter material may shift or wrinkle if not securely fastened.
Environmental and Safety Factors
Fiberglass roofing felt is often treated to improve fire resistance and reduce mold growth. Tar paper, containing higher tar content, may release fumes during installation, requiring adequate ventilation and protective gear.
Modern roofing felts using asphalt are generally considered more environmentally friendly than older tar-based products.
Summary Table: Roofing Felt vs Tar Paper
| Characteristic | Roofing Felt | Tar Paper |
|---|---|---|
| Base Material | Fiberglass or organic mat | Paper/cellulose fibers |
| Waterproofing Agent | Asphalt saturation | Tar impregnation |
| Thickness | Thicker, available in 15 lb & 30 lb | Thinner, lighter |
| Durability | High tear and weather resistance | Lower, prone to tearing |
| Typical Use | Long-term underlayment for roofs | Temporary protection, older roofing |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Installation Ease | More robust and less prone to damage | Requires careful handling, less robust |